Updated: Surprisingly good!
Score: 4/5 - Will take on the mafia again!
Intro: My Steam controller kicked the bucket and I got a Microsoft Xbox Wireless controller. Therefore, this updated review is based on playing the game with the new controller.
Pros
1. Action packed
2. Decent sound track
3. Good graphics
4. Engaging storyline
Cons
1. Don't even bother trying to play this with a Steam controller.
2. Stutters at times during car chases.
Verdict
This game is fun, gritty and full of action. There is the occasional stutter (when driving) but not enough to get me upset. The game is designed to be played with a controller (not the Steam controller, support for it is bad) and this is where you will get the most enjoyment out of it. As a newcomer to the Mafia series, I have to admit I am enjoying myself (enough to consider grabbing the Season Pass next time). Worth a buy when on sale but do yourself a favour and grab the complete (deluxe) package.